12 red flags in a strategy pitch

Most bad strategies are not frauds. They are honest mistakes presented with confidence. This checklist is ordered by how quickly each one kills a pitch.

Integrity

  1. No code, only a chart. An equity curve cannot be audited. If the code is not available, there is nothing to verify.
  2. "Proprietary" as a reason to hide the logic. Deterministic audits can run the code without you handing over the source — refusing even that is a signal.
  3. Returns that never draw down. A smooth line is the signature of lookahead, not skill.
  4. Sharpe above 8, or a 95%+ win rate over hundreds of trades. Not impossible; almost always a leak.
  5. Results that change between runs. Unseeded randomness or a wall-clock dependency means the number you were shown is one of many.

Method

  • No execution model. No orders, no fills, no slippage, no fees — the backtest trades at a price nobody could have got.
  • Full-sample normalisation. Any statistic computed across the entire history and used per row is future information.
  • Survivorship-biased universe. Today's index members applied to ten years of history quietly deletes every company that failed.
  • Parameter cliffs. A ±10% nudge destroys performance. You have found a spike, not an edge.
  • No out-of-sample period. Everything is in-sample; nothing was held back.
  • Presentation

  • One number, no denominator. "312% return" says nothing without drawdown, volatility, sample length, and the number of attempts.
  • No verification path. If the claim cannot be independently checked by a third party, it is marketing.
  • What a verifiable audit looks like

    The strategy runs in an isolated container, the run produces a manifest (input hash, dataset hash, strategy hash, engine version, seed), and the manifest is hashed. That hash is printed on the report and can be looked up later. If someone edits the report, the hash no longer matches.

    That is the difference between "trust me" and "check it yourself".

    Audit a strategy — 10 free credits